Part III 
How much difference does a year make when ranking the investment and development prospects for U.S. cities? Not as much as you might think given the market aftershocks from the credit crisis and economic concerns over housing woes.
The results from the Urban Land Institute's Emerging Trends in Real Estate 2008 survey still favors a handful of 24-hour cities as "Best in Show": New York, Washington, D.C., San Francisco, Boston, and Chicago, together with southern California stars and Seattle, easing up the inside rail.
The Triple Crown winner however is New York. Although New York has always been ranked at or near the top of Emerging Trends' surveys, New York has way surpassed its closest U.S. competitors. One interviewee from Chicago said, "It's a tale of two worlds - New York and everything else." Trophy buildings lease for three times as much in New York as in Chicago. "New York's fundamentals are out of the ballpark right now." Wall Street is a huge factor in New York's ascendancy and a derailment of the stock market could deeply effect the city's real estate market.
Emerging Trends mantra for investment prospects continues to be "global gateways" with emphasis on coastal cities followed by interior gateways such as Chicago, Atlanta, and Dallas. Must haves are high immigration flows and large international airports, major shipping ports, and/or export-import hubs. Access to global markets is key! "You need to be in the global pathways."
The following is a listing of how the investment and development prospects of metro areas stacked up from "Abysmal" to "Fair" to "Excellent". The ratings include the investment prospects for all property types from industrial to hotel, retail, apartments and homebuilding. Some of the more noticeable movement from the 2007 report is that Boston, San Jose, and Seattle moved up substantially and most Florida markets (except Miami, which stayed about the same), Las Vegas, and Atlanta were downgraded. If you will email me I will forward the actual chart which I was unable to import in a readable format here.
In the "Excellent" to "Fair" category for investment in all property types: Seattle, New York, Washington D.C., San Jose, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Honolulu/Hawaii, Austin, Boston, Raleigh/Durham, Portland, San Diego, Denver, Charlotte, Phoenix, Sacramento, Houston, Las Vegas, Orlando, Virginia Beach/Norfolk, Tampa/St. Pete, Miami, Salt Lake City, San Antonio, Chicago, Tucson, Atlanta, Jacksonville, Nashville, Dallas/Fort Worth, Baltimore, and Minneapolis/St. Paul.
In the "Fair" to "Abysmal" category for investment in all property types: Philadelphia, Indianapolis, Providence, Milwaukee, Kansas City, Memphis, St. Louis, Columbus, Cincinnati, Pittsburgh, Cleveland, New Orleans, and bringing up dead last...Detroit definitely in the Abysmal trash can. (ULI really doesn't mince words.)
It was a much shorter list for markets with prospects for homebuilding. The only markets considered by the survey to be above the "Fair" rating are: Seattle, Honolulu/Hawaii, Raleigh/Durham, San Francisco, New York, Portland, Washington, San Jose, Austin, Charlotte, Los Angeles, Salt Lake City, Houston, Dallas, and San Antonio.Here are some of the salient points on the individual markets:
Seattle. Developing into an exciting 24-hour city "smack-dab" on key Asian shipping routes. Corporate presence includes heavyweights like Microsoft, Boeing, Washington Mutual, Amazon, Costco and even Google. Multifamily and industrial sectors rate as the leading buy candidates in the entire survey. "Best West Coast value."
New York. "Catapulted beyond mere U.S. markets." The weak dollar makes the city look cheap next to top European markets. New York's suburbs are not nearly as strong as Manhattan.
Washington, D.C. Considered past its peak by respondents. Time to hold. Over leveraged deals may experience stress. No stress inside beltway and Maryland suburbs hold up, but Northern Virginia is more volatile.
Los Angeles. Housing market in the tank and Orange County office market softens. West LA office "has never been so good." Luxury markets across the board excel. Warehouse market is red hot. Good apartment market.
San Francisco. Big survey gains this year and heads back north on the list. Top market for hotel buy. Driven by the brain trust Mecca, 24-hour downtown, and gateway opportunities. San Francisco ranks as the survey's top hotel buy. Unrelenting Asian trade also makes warehouse a strong buy.
Boston. Known as a "hot and cold" office market, Boston is now enjoying a strong office scene although much of the financials have moved to greener pastures. No major building activity drives demand. High quality universities drive a quality talent pool and a vibrant downtown draws professionals. Housing prices on the decline but low affordability spurs renter demand and Boston apartments rate a strong buy signal.
San Diego. All markets are overpriced, expensive, and exhausted. Prime business centers migrate north. Small airport a negative for growth. Housing weak but say the respondents, "What a great unique place to live."
Denver. Downtown reinvents itself and their light rail system works beautifully. Textbook success story. The fast growing northern suburbs cluster around master-planned transit-oriented development linked directly to downtown. Downtown office is off the charts. Housing in check and apartments are firm. Kudos.
Phoenix. Perfectly positioned for solid growth as an affordable alternative to Southern California. Self-limiting land mines for Phoenix include poor city planning and infrastructure needs. Denver's success may be hard to repeat here. Office and apartments show some softening and stress on the housing sector put the area's growth in "slow gear".
Houston. High energy costs are boosting economy of real estate markets here. The Panama Canal expansion primes Houston's shipping and warehouse prospects drawing business from the West Coast ports. The easy-to-build environment lets developers get ahead of the market. High influx of people and growth for the the suburbs is continuous "with no zoning to get in the way."
Miami. Can be summed up with two words - "Condo mess." Miami held it's overall survey ranking however because the other market segments remain pretty stable. Because developers put all their attention into the condo mania and neglected other property types office prospects remain pretty good. The Miami warehouse market is one of the best in the nation. Latin American commerce and trade add market support. Tourism strong. Issues facing Miami are transportation, hurricane threat, taxes, and water.
Chicago. Ever optimistic developers continue to build in the office market causing softness in existing buildings. After rampant flipping prices are maxed out. Retail and hotels are firm but oversupply could be seen in industrial and apartments due to a full pipeline of projects coming online.
Atlanta. Chronically overdeveloped. Atlanta wrote the book on "boom-bust" developing. The economy is driven by growth and is "our engine and our enemy." Every sector is soft. Urban markets are growing but linear development makes a true center core difficult. The huge Atlanta International Airport positions the city as the Southeast's transport hub and link to global markets.
Dallas/Fort Worth. Like Atlanta, Dallas/Fort Worth loves to build and build and build. Office vacancies never seems to get below 20%. Pricing not as strong for commercial properties as in other national markets. Warehouse is unexpectedly strong now. "Investors have been wary of poor supply/demand fundamentals." Airport infrastructure puts the city on global pathways.
Heading north to the Canadian markets, interviewees appear more positive about 2008 prospects than their U.S. counterparts. Predictions look for an above average year but not in the spectacular range. U.S. housing woes have not extended to Canada as they clamped down early on the credit frenzy. "Property markets, including housing, track at or near equilibrium with high occupancies and controlled development."
Downtowns are the mainstay of the Canadian real estate markets. Residents, developers, planners, investors all gravitate to the city centers. "The hot-growth energy cities out west - Calgary and Edmonton - score the highest ratings for investment prospects, development, and for-sale housing, Toronto, Canada's premier global pathway city, and Vancouver also register strong scores. Ottawa and Montreal follow, and Halifax in the Eastern Maritime provinces lags."
Part I – Emerging Trends in Real Estate – A Dose of Fear
Part II – Emerging Trends in Real Estate – Best Bets for 2008
Part III - Emerging Trends in Real Estate - Markets to Watch